HackerTubewatch
Surprise me
Frame from Richard Feynman Fire Plays via YouTube's privacy-enhanced embed

Richard Feynman Fire

nebulajr
Interviews
YouTube
8 HN users recommended this interview8 months2010–2023 score 10
Years with an HN recommendation, 2007–2026

HN repeatedly cites it as an elegant, eye-opening explanation of fire and photosynthesis and as an example of Feynman's infectious love of knowledge.

A short clip from a Richard Feynman interview in which he explains fire, describing how burning wood releases sunlight stored by the tree, which built itself mostly from air. It showcases his curiosity and plain-spoken explanations.

“it's impossible to stay in any kind of negative mood if you watch Feynman” (HN, 2010)

4 strong recommendations · 4 recommendations · 6 citations · Interviews

14 Hacker News comments

From the HN archive; up to 20 kept per video, favoring different commenters. Recommendations first.

@drats Jul 2010 Strongly recommends
on HN thread The truth about cold water
I don't want to offend anyone but that article was extremely boring (I did end up reading it). I suppose I'd seen the Richard Feynman video on fire and trees quite recently beforehand and was in an intolerant mood. But it's impossible to stay in any kind of negative mood if you watch Feynman, his love of knowledge is just infectious. [this video]
Feynman on fire and trees; his love of knowledge is infectious.
@halfnelson Jun 2012 Strongly recommends
on HN thread Kids should be building rockets and robots, not taking standardized tests
If anyone wants to know the answer to that question, Richard Feynman explains it wonderfully: (He starts talking about trees at 2:00, but his explanation of fire is equally elegant!) [this video] My first instinct was to say that a tree's mass comes from dead stars. Imagining how it got from those stars to the air that eventually becomes the tree would keep you busy for a while :D
Feynman explains fire and trees wonderfully and elegantly.
@haxiomic Aug 2015 Strongly recommends
on HN thread GravityLight: Generate light with gravity
Checkout this explanation of fire by Richard Feynman - its a really eye opening perspective [this video] He explains the light of a fire is just the light of the Sun, it's just been stored in the wood
Fire's light is stored sunlight from the wood.
@jrscelza Jul 2020 Strongly recommends
on HN thread Richard Feynman cut straight to the heart of complex ideas
[this video] Feynman explains fire. I’m a big fan and believe his crude straight to the point style, coupled with an incredible ability to storytell is what made him special. I think it’s pure, genuine, curiosity and the intellectual capacity to understand the complexities.
Feynman's storytelling and genuine curiosity make fire explanation special.
@okamiueru Mar 2012 Recommends
on HN thread What is a flame -- how would you describe it to an 11 year old?
I'd really like to hear Richard Feynman's answer. I'm sure if an 11 year old had asked the question, instead of a journalist, it would be the perfect answer. (I'm referring to an interview series with him: [this video] ) Makes me sad to think I will never meet this man, nor ever be as awesome.
Feynman interview series with elegant explanations.
@js2 Apr 2021 Recommends
on HN thread Where does a candle go when it burns?
> Wax is made of hydrogen and carbon. Too bad he doesn't explain where the energy in the wax came from like Feynman does when explaining fire: [this video] Paraffin wax is derived from petroleum, so like the wood in Feynman's explanation, the energy is from the sun via ancient photosynthesis.
Feynman explains the sun as the energy source in burning wood.

Citations, criticism and jokes

@stcredzero Jan 2013 Cites it
on HN thread Elon Musk: Vegetarians only on Mars colony
Read more
> I suspect it's not about transportation costs so much as ecology. The amount of biomass available to animals at the top of the food pyramid is inversely proportional to the height of the pyramid. Right on. The thing to remember here, is that, as Feynmann says, plants make themselves out of air ! < [this video] > (If you doubt, go back to your basic biology education and remember the formula for photosynthesis.) So a Mars colony's farms are basically chemical solar collectors doing two things: 1) providing chemical energy to the colonists (food) and 2) Converting Martian CO2 and water into biomass. If you introduce too many warm blooded animals into the system, a lot of your energy input gets wasted as livestock body heat. tldr - By going vegetarian at first, the Mars colony accumulates usable biomass faster.
Feynman on plants making themselves out of air.
@stcredzero Jan 2013 Cites it
on HN thread Elon Musk: Vegetarians only on Mars colony
Read more
tldr - By going vegetarian at first, the Mars colony accumulates usable biomass faster. (Also, the "Up on the Farm" chapter of this book is a good background read for this discussion: [link] ) The thing to remember here, is that, as Feynmann says, plants make themselves out of air! < [this video] > Go back to your basic biology education and remember the formula for photosynthesis. < [link] > So a Mars colony's farms are basically chemical solar collectors doing two things: 1) providing chemical energy to the colonists (food) and 2) Converting Martian CO2 and water into biomass. If you introduce too many warm blooded animals into the system, a lot of your energy input gets wasted as livestock body heat. So by going vegetarian at first, the Mars colony accumulates usable biomass faster. The faster you accumulate biomass, the faster you can make more biomass. This is also the principle behind the tactic of mostly making construction vehicles at first in Starcraft, or concentrating early on customer acquisition in a startup.
Feynman on plants making themselves out of air.
@reggieband Jan 2021 Cites it
on HN thread Why Combustion Is Exothermic
I first learned the idea of fire as breaking molecular bonds formed during photosynthesis from a video snippet of Richard Feynman [1]. 1. [this video]
Source for fire as breaking bonds formed in photosynthesis.
@surprisetalk Feb 2023 Cites it
on HN thread Ask HN: How to protect blog from AI search?
Read more
This is an extremely difficult question that I've been grappling with myself. My first strategy is to create writings that can't be summarized. I try to make essays that are dripping with idiosyncrasy. I can't win in an information war, but I can stay competitive for ~10 years in a creative clash: [1] [link] [2] [link] [3] [link] [4] [link] [5] [link] I myself draw lots of my inspiration from my "sages of style", in the same way that AIs will try to replicate my voice. None of these great thinkers can be summarized or replicated in any meaningful way: [6] David Foster Wallace: [link] [7] George Carlin: [link] [8] Derek Sivers: [link] [9] John Green: [link] [10] Roman Mars: [link] [11] Alan Kay: [link] [12] Alan Watts: [link] [13] Richard Feynman: [this video] [14] Raymond Smullyan: [link] But style only takes you so far. My second strategy is to socialize IRL. This year, I'm starting a tech conference called "Outland" to foster community in an age where community might be all that matters. [15] [link]
Feynman listed among thinkers whose style can't be summarized.
@philip1209 Nov 2023 Cites it
on HN thread Ask HN: Comment here about whatever you're passionate about at the moment
Trees are renewable. The mass of a tree comes from the carbon it extracts from the air. [1] It's not a zero-sum, though. Why does my cilantro need to come in a plastic bag? At the farmer's market, it doesn't come packaged. [1] And, fire is basically reversing the process - releasing the sunlight that created the plant: [this video]
Fire releases the sunlight that created the plant.

Video list and Hacker News comment labels from HackerTube (prompted by @karpathy), released under ODC-By 1.0, built on the open-index/hacker-news archive. Hacker News data is provided by Y Combinator; comments remain the work of their authors. Video titles, channel names and thumbnails belong to their creators and are shown via YouTube. HackerTube Watch is an unofficial edition. Data export of 2026-10-31.

Keyboard shortcuts

/
Search
j k
Next / previous video
r
Surprise me
l
Like (video page)
w
Watch later (video page)
?
This help
Esc
Close